[ecis2016.org] Starting April 1, 2019, developers can choose the new GST rate for under-construction properties, with lower tax, albeit without ITC. We examine the implications that this change is likely to bring, for developers and home buyers alike
As announced during the interim budget 2019, the GST Council has reviewed the Goods and Services Tax (GST) rates on the real estate sector. Accordingly, the developers of residential projects which are incomplete as on March 31, 2019, will get a one-time option to either choose the old GST rates of 8% and 12% on affordable housing and non-affordable housing, respectively, with input tax credit (ITC), or to shift to the new 1% and 5% rates, for affordable housing and non-affordable housing, respectively, without the ITC.
Higher GST with ITC or lower GST rates without ITC: What will developers choose?
With the input tax credit being taken away, there will be an immediate cost implication for developers. However, it is up to the developers to decide if they want to clear their existing inventory by adopting the reduced rate regime, or stick to the previous arrangement should their profit margins be tighter and if they are confident of clearing the inventory at higher GST rates to the end-user. “It is a business call that each developer will have to make, as per their assessment of their own and market conditions and liquidity conditions,” says Nimish Gupta, FRICS-MD, south Asia, RICS.
For the projects launched before April 1, 2019, the GST Council allows the developers to stick with the old GST rates, with ITC benefit. “So, the developers are likely to go with the old GST rate for those projects, as they have already factored the sale price keeping in mind the GST and in many cases the benefit of ITC was passed on to the buyers,” says Harvinder Singh Sikka, MD of the Sikka Group.
With the emphasis presently being on volume growth, the pressure on property prices is likely to remain. Moreover, with demand remaining subdued in most micro-markets, several developers have even resorted to fully absorbing the impact of GST, in the form of concessions and discounts.
Aditya Kedia, managing director of Transcon Developers, points out that the GST regime considers the share of land at one-third of the total value of the project. “However, real estate projects within city limits have a land cost at 40-50% of the total cost. Developers focusing on the affordable housing sector are likely to be affected by the ITC withdrawal, because the share of cost of construction is likely to be higher in this sector,” Kedia explains.
[ecis2016.org] GST Council approves transition plan for 5% rate for under-construction flats, and 1% for affordable housing
Reduced GST rate for real estate: Impact on property prices
When the rate of tax decreases, the value of a product or service should also perceive a corresponding reduction. However, the structure of GST is such that in some cases, particularly where the ITC cannot be claimed, the prices may not decrease. This implies that the planned decrease in GST rates for under-construction housing projects, may not result in lower values of residential units. It may also raise the level of complexity for developers.
Experts also warn of some confusion, as buyers would want to shift to the new lower tax regime, while builders may want to continue with the earlier regime of higher GST but with ITC. “In the current situation, it may lead to some conflict of interest between buyers and sellers. It may also leave little room for developers to increase residential property prices. They may have to wait for greater clarity on the same, to ensure a smooth transition,” says Abhinav Joshi, head of research, CBRE India.
He adds that a similar situation may arise, for mixed-use developments. This may result in delays in project execution, as developers may have to revisit their budgeting and renegotiate with existing supply partners, to ensure that they meet the requirement of procuring from GST-compliant vendors.
Moreover, the raw materials that form a part of any construction project, will still be taxed at the prevalent rates. “For example, the rate of tax on cement is 28%, while that on elevators is 18%. Such prices and duties that are paid by the developer, may be indirectly passed on to the consumer,” says Kedia. The withdrawal of ITC could reduce developers’ turnover, as it would be difficult for developers to absorb the snowballing cost of construction. This could lead to an escalation in property prices, as developers strive to avert unwanted pressure on margins. “As a result of this, developers in order to uphold margins, would be forced to raise the sale price by 5-6%,” Kedia cautions.
Going forward, if developers choose the new regime, it is likely to mean an increase in the cost of construction. However, the end-user may benefit from the lower GST rates, if the increase in costs are not passed on through a price revision.
Impact of new GST rates on the real estate fraternity
Copyright belongs to: ecis2016.org